Login | Register |  
Front Page

Brotherhood: Season 1 review (DVD) ★★★★

Review by Adam Stephen Kelly
Stars
Jason Clarke, Jason Isaacs, Annabeth Gish, Kevin Chapman, Fiona C Erickson,
Brian Scannell, Fionnula Flanagan, Kerry O'Malley, Madison Garland, Billy Smith, Ethan Embry, Brian F O'Byrne

UK Certification 18 | UK RRP £24.99 | DVD Region 2 | Runtime 560 minutes | Created by Blake Masters


Lasting only three seasons because of tragically low viewing figures, Brotherhood was a show that really did deserve to have a far larger audience, though I can see exactly why it didn't do so well in the ratings, as I myself almost fell into the same spot of bother.

It's not a show that you can just jump in and out of or catch halfway through a season and somehow get involved in. You have to be with it from the first episode and right through to the end to fully appreciate it. It's not brimming with excitement, it's not overly eventful, and it's far less emphatic than The Sopranos, which it likens itself to, but what it very much is is gripping, intelligent drama with a wonderful cast, great writing and deliciously nuanced dialogue.

In Brotherhood, two brothers at opposite sides of the law make it their own personal quest to reign over The Hill, a small and predominantly Irish neighbourhood in the picturesque Providence, Rhode Island. Michael Caffee, a gangster with a bloodstained history of murder who returns to The Hill after seven years of being presumed dead, and Tommy Caffee, a politician hoping to rise through the ranks in his bid to eventually become Mayor, are bound unconditionally by brotherly love, but their relationship is sent on a rollercoaster ride as, between death and crooked politics, they clash like black and white, which is essentially what they both are: polar opposites.

But dirty politics and the countless illegalities of being a gangster barely scratch the surface of what Brotherhood entails. Tommy's wife lives in the personal turmoil of a midlife crisis, depressed, paranoid and reliant on alcohol, pot and cocaine, and to make matters worse, her teenage daughter has become aware of a couple of her secrets and, at the tender age that she is, has been influenced by her 'extracurricular activities'. And friends and family everywhere seem to each be falling apart at the seams, as a fellow gangster battles to stay sober after beating the booze, and the Caffee matriarch struggles to adapt to life in an ever-changing society that is losing its tradition and values.

It's never overly ambitious in its storytelling and the everyone-knows-everyone community of The Hill is a perfect location for the scandalous behaviour of its residents. Brotherhood is slow-burning but that's exactly what makes it so refreshingly good. And what's the problem with a show where the two leads nail perfect Rhode Island accents when they're Australian and Scottish respectively?

EXTRAS ★ Just a stills gallery and cast bios and filmographies. What is this, 1999? A terrible shame as far as special features go, especially on a TV series.

» | Brotherhood: Season 1 review (DVD) ★★★★ | delicious | digg | reddit | newsvine | google | technorati-